What's the real reason we play video games?

Width
Text
ThemeLight theme

"Frankly, I've been trying to find the answer [to why I love games] for a while.  My "tastes" are so varied, ranging from pure "gameplay catharsis" to story driven to aesthetics/mood pieces [...].  Music and film fills me emotionally, books provide good literature, learning and all, but with games I don't know it feels...  I guess new and full of potential.  The interactivity certainly plays a part of it, but I don't know, I can't explain.  When I see a particular landscape my mind goes to a state of awe."

— Reddit comment, lightly edited for readability

It's September 9, 2014, and we're approaching midnight. People across 178 countries are lined up in front of over 11,000 video game retailers.  Doors will open at exactly midnight — yes, in the middle of the night.  Why?  Because that is when they will legally be allowed to sell copies of the latest game from a group of developers that are fast becoming legends.  Their studio is called Bungie, their new game is Destiny, and it will make over $500M in sales in a single day.

There is a special energy surrounding video games.  Those who play them can sense it in their favourite title.  Those who don't, get glimpses of it when they hear stories like the above.  Or when some crazy industry statistic makes the headlines yet again.  Nearly half of the world plays video games regularly — girls, boys, men, women, babies and elders alike.  We collectively spent somewhere around 750 billion hours playing games last year — that's over 1 million human lifespans.  The medium clearly took the world by storm.  In 1962, video games were barely more than a few moving pixels on the screens of MIT computers.  By 1983, Trip Hawkins — founder of Electronic Arts — was declaring that a new art form was born.  Except that by then, a 1976 article in the Daily Oregonian had already triggered a moral panic and launched the debate about the real reason people play video games.  Many argued that far from being a new form of art, this was a dangerous new addiction that was quickly corrupting the minds of young men.

So, what's the real reason we play video games?  Are we all addicted?  Or are we expanding our minds through works that (at their best) have the potential to inspire us in the way Beethoven's 5th Symphony and Michelangelo's Sistine Chapel can?  That question has been on my mind before I even conceived of working in the games industry, and in the past 15 years I think it fair to say that it has been my most consuming area of professional interest.  I have read nearly every research paper I could get my hands on, watched nearly every conference talk, and read multiple books from industry leaders.  For 15 years I have been sitting down to have people tell me all about their favourite games, sometimes for a whole hour — something which I still consider to be an immense pleasure and privilege.  And I believe the answer is... somewhat more complicated — and also immensely more interesting — than most people give it credit for.

This blog is dedicated to exploring this exact question.  To answer it, however, will require much more than a single post.  Not only because this is my first blog and I need time to warm up to the writing (I definitely do); also because I believe the debate deserves better than the kind of answers and attention it is currently getting.  I believe that the magic feeling we get from our favourite games is more than a hypnotizing spectacle.  I truly believe — and I was writing essays about this when still in college — that video games as a medium hold an immense potential that we've barely begun to discover.

I propose, then, to start from the very beginning of my own journey: what would you find, today, if you were to look for an answer to the real reason why people play video games?

Interested? Sign up to be notified when new essays drop.

A new art form: you want games that make you cry.

Trip Hawkins may have been one of the first to publicly argue for video games as a form of art, but he was far from the last.  One of the fiercest advocates of this view — and someone regarded by many as a creative genius — is Hideo Kojima.  Most well known as the mind behind Metal Gear, Kojima is unusually outspoken and articulate among successful developers.  He calls video games a "sōgō geijutsu".  A concept coined in Germany (as best as I can ascertain) in the mid-1800s by such greats as Richard Wagner, a sōgō geijutsu is a "total art form" that tries to integrate as many other arts as possible (i.e. music, visual arts, performance, literature, architecture, etc.).  More specifically, however, Kojima argues that games are unique among sōgō geijutsu in how much they rely on the dynamic interplay between the game and the player.  The player doesn't merely experience the work of art: they literally complete it through play.  Much like how, in a story by poet Rumi, a Chinese mural that reflected on a polished Greek wall seemed to come alive through an added shimmering effect.

It may be tempting to write off this high view of video games as relevant only to one of the industry's elites, reflecting on his work while approaching the end of a long and distinguished career.  Except that, not only are his views shared by a large number of the most prominent developers across the world, they are arguably at the very root of the explosive success of the industry as a whole.  In 1983, games like Pac-Man were thriving in arcades while the home console market was crashing after too many low-quality games flooded the market.  Most people at the time assumed that the real future of video games was in classrooms, as educational software.  In 1983, you had to be hungry and foolish to invest your time and money in a home video game studio.  You had to be doubly foolish to post a full-page recruitment ad in a newspaper that asked: "Can a computer make you cry?"  You really had to be out of your mind to claim that video games were the only computer software with the "enormous potential" to be "worthy of the minds that use it".  You had to be young, hungry and foolish like Trip Hawkins, who claimed exactly this in a recruiting ad for Electronic Arts (EA), a company he invested his personal savings into just a year earlier and whose most emotionally-deep game at the time was arguably a clone of the board game Clue called Murder on the Zinderneuf.  EA may have had the most iconic ad, but its views weren't the exception.  Many of the industry's giants, from Activision to Blizzard and Nintendo, share similar roots.  It's widely accepted — or at least it was — that the industry we know today was built by people with a deep passion for the medium; something I can personally vouch for after working with many talented and passionate people at Ubisoft and Electronic Arts, and hearing firsthand their experiences through the 1990s and 2000s.  And yes: computers can now make people cry.

Games obviously vary wildly in scope and richness.  For those who have felt the magic in a particular game, however, the passion and creativity of its developers is undeniable.  Why then, if games have such a potential, are they so often painted as some dangerous substance invading the minds of the young and vulnerable, as if we're talking about drugs flowing through the streets?

The fall from grace: you're addicted to games.

The idea that video games are addictive has experienced a surge in popularity in recent years, as more and more game studios seem to have learned how to condition people's emotions (which is not limited to dopamine, but that is a story for another time).  There's still debate among psychiatrists and psychologists about exactly what should define video game addiction, or indeed whether gaming is even a new form of addiction.  Nevertheless, it's become hard to argue with the phenomenon at large when players themselves voluntarily seek help to tackle their problematic gaming habits.  Read Cam Adair's story or watch his TEDx talk if you want a particularly touching and nuanced account.

Believe it or not, however, we didn't need any of the modern — and sometimes mind-blowingly intricate — reward and appointment mechanics of games like World of Warcraft and Destiny 2 to cause a general panic.  Parts of the industry might have shifted focus from passionate craftsmanship to behavioural engineering, but there were already concerns about psychiatric complications due to video games back in 1982.  Because of Space Invaders.  Yes, this Space Invaders, which young men reported "fantasizing [about] before falling asleep".  Let's just say things were quickly getting out of hand.  And researchers rose to meet the new challenge. They claimed that video games were making people violent, depressed, anxious and lonely — feeding a stereotype that still survives to some extent.  In the past 40 years, there has been plenty of research that supported these views, and also plenty that contradicted them.  What is most disappointing to me, however, is not that we can't even settle the debate; it's that after all of this science, there is still no sign of a causal model that could begin to explain how, when and why video games might harm people.  To make things even more interesting, some research even suggests that games can have a positive impact on one's well-being (we'll return to this shortly).

Perhaps because the science remains so murky, many prominent public figures shifted their rhetoric from games as addictive to games as a complete waste of time.

Admit it: you're just wasting your time.

Among internet figures discussing the impact video games have on our minds, few are more prominent than Andrew Huberman and Jordan Peterson.  Andrew Huberman teaches neuroscience and runs a lab at Stanford.  Jordan Peterson had a long career as both a clinician and professor of clinical psychology at the University of Toronto.  In recent years, both have gathered large audiences on social media and published highly successful books, most often focusing on health and well-being.  Both have been repeatedly asked for their opinions on video games.  And both share, to a large extent, the same view.  A view which shows that the debate has in fact evolved over time, since it sits somewhere between "games are addictive" and "games are an art form" (though admittedly much closer to the former).

In short: games do turn out to be exceedingly good at delivering certain very meaningful experiences, but they do so in a way that completely robs these experiences of any real value to you.  I say this at least begins to rescue the "games are an art form" idea because it goes beyond games as a mere drug or channel for pent-up aggression.  Video games don't just create the illusion of progress by delivering dopamine to the brain: they set up a situation where people legitimately dedicate huge amounts of effort towards acquiring and developing skills, or possibly completing certain projects.  They create rich mythologies that let players enact in vivid detail classic narrative structures, like that of the hero saving the kingdom from the very essence of evil, or the underdog undergoing a rags-to-riches story of epic proportions despite overwhelming odds against them.  We could keep going.  I might be slightly generous with their own descriptions here, but the real point is this: despite all of the richness and apparent meaningfulness of some of our gaming experiences, none of it amounts to anything.  Never mind that one might spend hours staring at a black canvas in New York's Museum of Modern Art.  Never mind also the (otherwise excellent) nearly 2-hour lecture Huberman will give you on the power of play.  Or Peterson's insistence on the power of stories — including those in books and movies.  No.  The time you spent playing and replaying NieR: Automata was definitely a complete waste of time.

These are people whose exposure to games is primarily through their patients, which would definitely influence their views.  Strangely, however, given their heavy reliance on scientific research, they both fail to tell the whole story about video games' impact on our well-being.  And there is definitely more to this particular story.

A redemption story on the horizon?  You play to satisfy basic human needs.

We come, finally, to one of my favourite topics.  The surprisingly recent idea that games might fulfill some basic and important psychological needs.  I say surprisingly because the idea that play itself is important is comparatively much older.  Jean Piaget and Bärbel Inhelder worked for decades to establish how crucial play was in psychological development.  Piaget's most famous book on the topic was published in 1951 — a whole 30 years before video games became mainstream.  Even the specific theory that would come to be applied to games (Self-Determination Theory) had been popular since 1985.  Yet it wasn't until 2006 that anyone tried to ask whether video games might actually contribute to well-being.  But when Ryan, Rigby and Przybylski did publish their 2006 paper on "The Motivational Pull of Video Games", the results did not disappoint.

In what is almost certainly still the most widely cited paper on this topic, the authors shared a series of studies with impressive scope.  They demonstrated that need satisfaction could predict enjoyment and desire to play.  They showed that different games can satisfy each need differently — and that different players may "get" something different from the same game.  They connected need satisfaction by games with short-term well-being (in the form of vitality, self-esteem and mood).  They showed that need satisfaction was a better predictor of many of these outcomes than players' overt motives — things like a desire for achievement, socializing or immersion.  Their results even suggested that playing for the "wrong" reasons leads to a drop in well-being.  All while publishing a questionnaire (a validated scientific instrument required for good research) that is still in use 20 years later.

So, does that mean the debate is finally settled?  I'm afraid not.  Despite what I still consider to be a huge breakthrough in the field, relatively little progress has been made in the 20 years since its publication.  Meaningful work has been done, to be sure, with a lot of contributions by Johannes, Magnusson, Przybylski and Vuorre from the Oxford Internet Institute.  One of their studies confirmed that games can enhance well-being in the very short-term, especially for more casual games and players.  Yet, another study surveyed over 38,000 players and showed little to no overall effect on well-being when looking across different games and players.  These results are important to move science forward, though I suspect they won't help silence any critics.  More importantly, however, none of this provides any guidance to players, parents and therapists who want to make space for the magic that video games can deliver, while guarding against their worst aspects.  And it is not just conclusive results that are lacking.  We have yet to see a single study that takes into account how well players are able to meet their own needs outside of games, and whether that changes the effect that gaming has on them.  We have barely even begun to come up with the vocabulary for how to talk about games in this way.

Thankfully, we are not yet done with our review — and the real seed of hope might be just around the corner.

Learning to take the corner: fun games with serious results.

The Need for Speed games were among my favourite as a teenager.  The ultra-high speed police pursuits.  The jaw-dropping vistas.  The beautifully detailed cars.  One of my particularly salient memories with the franchise had me driving at high speed on a highly picturesque road winding up and down what must have been a European mountain range.  Then, as I was about to take my next turn, the game suddenly paused for a tutorial: to take a corner with maximum speed, it informed me, I should brake from the opening to the apex of the turn, then accelerate again.  I'm not even sure I had taken my first driving class at the time, yet that tutorial still influences how I drive today.  In fact, the research of the past 20 years suggests that all of the time I've spent playing simulation racing games almost certainly made me a better driver overall.  It definitely helped me win more than one go-kart race.

Play and learning are so deeply intertwined that it becomes equally easy to dismiss the fact as trivial, as it is to elevate it as one of the grandest ideas.  Play is a fundamental biological drive most (if not all) mammals share.  It's how we learn about the world as kids. It's how we learn new crafts and professions as adults.  Play drives scientific discoveries.  Artists and intellectuals invite us to play with their works.  And video games aren't the exception.  Teachers introduced Minecraft in classrooms as soon as it was released.  Computer simulations make better airplane pilots.  One study showed surgeons making up to 47% fewer errors during testing if they played video games regularly (though others argue the effect may go away with training).  Someone designed a game (called SPARX) to teach kids struggling with depression how to manage their thoughts and emotions, which showed a 65% higher remission rate than standard treatments.  Another teaches people about cyber-security.  Games can lead to scientific discoveries.  People who play video games are sometimes shown to have greater creativity than those who use computers and mobiles for other activities.  A study found that playing games can boost learning speed in unrelated tasks.  Playing games seems to protect against dementia, similar to how cognitive activities in general might slow cognitive decline.  And in what must surely be the Grand Finale of all video game achievements (or should I say the final boss?), players are having serious discussions about games and transcendent spiritual experiences — all while academics write on the deep relationships between games and religion.  

Yet, the most comprehensive review ever published on the topic concluded that no amount or type of game has any impact on cognition whatsoever — all we find is placebo effects and other biases.  How is that possible?  Because an astonishingly large number of studies — the majority in fact — mash together games of all types, played by people of all backgrounds, for arbitrary amounts of time in arbitrary conditions of play, then ask whether games can improve the most fundamental, difficult-to-train cognitive abilities they can think of.  All with the appearance of the utmost scientific rigor and frontier-level thinking.

I deem it extremely reasonable to think that in the best of times, we do choose to play games because they stimulate our senses, challenge our cognition and develop our sensitivities on many levels.  To think that whether video games turn out to be a curse or a boon for you personally — and for society as a whole — will be decided by what we play, when, why, how, and how much.  For these questions to be settled scientifically, however, they need to be asked in the first place.

The important answers come after the right questions

So, what is the real reason people play video games?  Why are we sometimes so passionate about a particular game?  Should we take games seriously as artworks, educational tools, or even clinical treatments?  Perhaps to start getting better answers, we have to start by asking better questions.  Computers can now make us cry.  What else do they have the potential to achieve?  How can we make games that touch and satisfy their players' real needs?  How do we kindle — or rediscover — the joy and passion video games can deliver?  How do we guide and support the gaming habits of those we care about to make sure they don't fall into a vicious cycle, whether that is due to a lack of maturity or a purposefully engineered habit?

There are a lot of conflicting (and sometimes confusing) answers out there, and many, many more questions that don't even get asked.  Science will almost certainly provide better answers in the course of time, but it is first up to the pioneering artists and engineers, together with their passionate fans, to demonstrate the true potential of video games.  I think that is the real question most people have on their mind when they ask "the question" about video games: what is their potential, and how do we avail ourselves of that potential?  From a ship shooting bobbing aliens and two paddles ricocheting a pixelated ball back and forth, we have arrived at persistent online worlds, inhabited by millions of players, who organize themselves in complex social institutions, complete with their own cultural norms and trade-based economies.  Video games might be the most powerful psycho-technology humanity has ever invented.  I wish that through my blog and work, I might make some small contribution to what we all take away from them.

Stay playful,

Vincent

Interested? Sign up to be notified when new essays drop.